Brokeback Mountain Review

"Brokeback Mountain" reviews

Movie

Brokeback Mountain

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2006-04-19 23:10:00

Rating

3.5/5

Provider

CinemaSource

Review

If you have the patience to sit through a slow-moving romance and you lack the vanity to be put off by explicit cowboy on cowboy relations, you'll greatly appreciate the light at the end of Brokeback Mountain, a work of art that's more than just a movie.

Story

In 1963, Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) show up penniless at a Wyoming ranch to look for work. The strangers are quickly assigned to herd sheep together on Brokeback Mountain. Be it the pristine setting in which they live, sleep and work together or the appearance that they're practically the last two people left on earth, something draws them together, and before long they share a tent and a raw liaison. In order to keep their jobs, they know they must keep this secret affair just that, and must decide on a larger scale whether or not to embrace their emerging love. Over the next 20 years, the two men—almost as if by familial rite of passage—marry and become fathers, but find themselves drawn back together. But can they ever find the happiness they shared together on Brokeback Mountain in the real world?

Acting

Be prepared for, at the very least, an Oscar nomination for Ledger, who painstakingly embodies the plights that his character would actually face. The plights for a gay cowboy stuck in the most unforgiving of cultural and societal climates are many, and, well, could there have been a tougher character to portray this year, save for Johnny Cash and Truman Capote? Which is certainly not to take anything away from Gyllenhaal's work here (or in Jarhead)—Jack is more willing to submit to the love, reducing his character's complexity but not the actor's dramatic fireworks, which are nothing short of captivating. Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway co-star as the cowboys' wives, possibly deserving of Oscar nods of their own had their roles been bigger.

Direction

For director Ang Lee, Brokeback signals a dazzling return to his roots. Don't let Lee's Hulk aberration fool you, for this is a daring director who helmed The Ice Storm and Oscar-winner Sense and Sensibility. Brokeback finds Lee dissecting the humanity and the lack thereof in a relationship that goes beyond mere gender. But more importantly, he explores the threshold of the alpha male as an incorrigible creature. The film is also stunning, almost hypnotizing, visually with much of the story unfolding against the lush nature of Wyoming. And the score by Gustavo Santaolalla befits the ambiance perfectly without ever being intrusive. All in all, the film could've stood to trim a few minutes, but it just might be Lee's best to date. (Plus, expect a major boon for the fashion industry, as hipsters might again be sportin' skin-tight cowboy duds--and boots--in '06!)

Bottom Line

Hollywood.com rated this film 3 1/2 stars.

Movie

BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2006-02-02 17:01:56

Provider

MRIB

Review

Based on Annie Proulx's short story, this compelling study of homophobia amongst modern day cowboys is a powerful and deeply moving movie from director Ang Lee.

Jack Twist and Ennis Del Mar are a young, budding rodeo rider and a ranch hand for hire in the 1960s. Finding work over winter at a Wyoming sheep ranch they forge a lifelong bond. Initially, going their separate ways to build very different lives with different wives the two remain tied by their deep, but hidden and forbidden, love for each other. Later in life, and over the many years that follow, they re-ignite their relationship by regularly escaping to the wilderness together under the premise of hunting and fishing trips; seeking moments of solace from their impossible situation in each others close company.

This difficult plot - that still engenders resistance, frowns and denial in certain parts of small town USA - is tenderly executed. the performances of Jake Gyllenhaal and as the two men unable to fully accept or publicly show their feelings for each other due to the pressures of their environment are outstanding. Ledger's strong, earthy performance as Ennis deserves particular praise. The prescient pain and turmoil of his character is writ large across every scene he appears in. Set against the vast landscapes and vistas the story inhabits Ang Lee has managed to capture not only their love, pain and strain; but also the broader spirit of struggle in modern day America for the working man. In able support Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway are the wives living first unaware, then in distress and denial of the depth of their husbands' relationship.

With no positive resolution visible for the characters, it is a testament to Ang Lee's continuingly deft touch and film-making talent that you'll leave the cinema filled with warmth and optimism.

Brokeback Mountain Review