Good Shepherd, The Review

View our special Good Shepherd, The feature!

"Good Shepherd, The" reviews

Movie

Good Shepherd, The

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2007-02-12 22:41:16

Rating

2/5

Provider

CinemaSource

Review

Lots of gray cloaks and very sporadic daggers makes director Robert De Niro's The Good Shepherd a realistic spy story, but not a box-office crowd pleaser.

Story

The Good Shepherd is billed as the story of how the CIA began, but it is really the fictional story of Edward Wilson (Matt Damon) and his involvement in the first covert wing of the CIA. The story moves back and forth in time from when Edward is a literature student at Yale and a member of the secretive Skull and Bones club, through the days following the Bay of Pigs in the early '60s. Edward is recruited into intelligence work at the beginning of World War II, and learns the dark art of spying and espionage from the British. Meanwhile, his personal life takes a back seat to his service for his country, including alienating his wife Margaret "Clover" Wilson (Angelina Jolie) and their son. He is never home enough to effectively deal with the family problems his absence creates. By the end of the film, as the twin disasters of the Bay of Pigs and his broken family unfold--and blame must be assigned--Edward ends up being a metaphor for the modern US intelligence service.

Acting

Damon, who has made a franchise out of playing the spy/assassin Bourne, plays a very different kind of spy in The Good Shepherd. Wilson is a boring, controlled, buttoned down spy, who is unfortunately more like the real thing than what we see in the movies. Damon does an excellent job, however, especially in those moments when he realizes he has screwed up. The actor stays controlled but finds a way to let the audience glimpse the pain of a man who has spent his life keeping his emotions and thoughts under wraps. Jolie is almost too luminous for the part of Edward's hapless wife. She is a bright spot in the movie, as she transforms from the sexy/feisty Clover to the medicated/angry Margaret. Newcomer Eddie Redmayne also does a good job as the grown up Edward Wilson Jr. The rest of the cast is peppered with excellent performances from top-flight actors, including William Hurt, as a menacing intelligence heavy; Michael Gambon (Dumbledore in the Harry Potter series), as a British intelligence officer who's fed up—and even De Niro himself, as a general who's the driving force behind the CIA's beginning.

Direction

De Niro captures the nature of the gray-flannelled spy but seems to get bogged down with material, unable to craft a tight, compelling film. The Good Shepherd is long and feels long, with some of the transitions too abrupt. The subdued colors evoke the period of the film, as well as play into the monotony that is intelligence work. But the problem with monotony is that it's boring, and boring is not something a movie should be. There are some incredibly intriguing scenes, however, and the film will certainly speak to any of those with genuine interests in the hardcore spy genre--obviously De Niro being one of them--but like its subject matter, Shepherd will probably be too elusive for the casual viewer. De Niro seems much more comfortable in the details but less interested in keeping the story gripping. Ironically, this is the exact opposite of the main character Edward Wilson, who keeps his eye on the big picture but misses the small moments he should have noticed.

Bottom Line

Hollywood.com rated this film 2 stars.

Movie

The Good Shepherd

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2007-02-16 16:00:26

Provider

Review

De Niro's directing delivers a subtle and poignant story using the pre and early days of the CIA to tell the very human story of one of it's formidable yet, calm and calculating men, Edward Wilson - expertly realised by Matt Damon.

Edward Wilson appears as an anonymous, average, everyday American to most. In actual fact he is one of the key figures in creating the behemoth that is CIA - not 'The CIA' as one character opines… "you don't put 'the' in front of 'God'." We meet Wilson as the Bay of Pigs fiasco is instigated by the USA. As an influential executor of the flawed invasion of Cuba it is the nadir of Wilson's career. However, time lapse storytelling takes us back to his school days and childhood, tracking back and forth though key highlights and traumas of his life and career - counter intelligence in WWII, a failing marriage and tempestuous relationship with his son, to lost relationships with his father and a girlfriend of his youth and meeting his opposing nemesis from Russian intelligence, code-named Ulysses.

Without ever breaking into flag-waving or salute it's interspersed with his embrace by the USA's political and social elite, some groundbreaking spy work and, surprisingly, some stupendous espionage errors.

Do not go expecting tension-heavy spy-telling and action here. Like De Niro's debut direction, A Bronx Tale, this is the story of a boy's journey into (and this time through) adulthood. The key here is Wilson's attitude and approach: a focussed, methodical and effective man with a work ethic that ultimately permeates and dominates his person. It leads to his too late and ultimately unresolved realisation that his fate was by no means sealed during his early life and naive youth - all plans and ideals gone dramatically awry.

The cast is superb - leads Damon and, particularly, Jolie, who's exemplary as his long-suffering wife going from powerful, emotional, modern young woman to middle-aged sorrow-filled lost soul with aplomb. De Niro captures the best of a substantially talented cast, as well a multitude of significant cameos - that were no doubt queuing up for the opportunity to work with him.

Over ten years in the making, the film runs for approaching 3 hours. However, it's non-linear structure creates an edge of the seat and simpatico mood. As you realise, before Wilson, his is a forlorn life that is at odds with his patriotic ethics, morals and stellar, but forever secret, career success.

Highest quality moviemaking that first shrouds a man's life and a CIA man's life behind the secrecy and deception in both, but cleverly draws back all the covers to expose his truth.