The Golden Compass Review

View our special The Golden Compass feature!

"The Golden Compass" reviews

Movie

The Golden Compass

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2009-10-21 21:36:35

Rating

3/5

Provider

CinemaSource

Review

Although this might be a tad convoluted and distant for the younger set, The Golden Compass is still a truly fantastical journey filled with wondrous imagery. A real visual treat.

Story

Based on the first of Philip Pullman's bestselling fantasy trilogy, The Golden Compass follows along the same lines as the Harry Potter series. It is set in a parallel universe very much like our own, but not quite, in which there are witches who fly the skies, armored ice bears who rule the north, and individual animal spirits called ''daemons'' who are intricately joined to their human counterparts. And of course there is also the whole good vs. evil milieu. The bad guys in this scenario are the Magisterium, a group of high-minded intellectuals running the joint who want to control all of humanity by basically eliminating free will. Our heroine is 12-year-old Lyra Belacqua (Dakota Blue Richards), who turns out to be the Magisterium's greatest threat because she is the child destined to possess the last remaining Golden Compass, a truth-telling device. Still with me? Her uncle, the scientist Lord Asriel (Daniel Craig), is captured by the Magisterium, while a benefactress, Mrs. Coulter (Nicole Kidman), takes Lyra under her wing--mind you, not for benevolent reasons. Escaping Mrs. Coulter's clutches, Lyra sets out to find her loyal friend, who has mysteriously joined the hundreds of children currently disappearing without a trace. Her adventure takes her over sky and ocean to the north, and with her band of friends and allies--and the power of the Golden Compass--Lyra will need all her skill and courage to stop the war that's coming. Whew, that's a tall order to fill for one little girl.

Acting

But don't let the little-girl act fool you. As played by the lovely Richards in her debut performance, Lyra is one tough cookie, seemingly unafraid of the challenges she faces, including confronting a 12-foot-tall polar bear charging at her, among other things. Much like Daniel Radcliffe before her, the plucky actress is quite a find and should The Golden Compass trilogy continue, she'll be an indelible part of it. As will Kidman and Craig, as the yin-and-yang parental figures in Lyra's life--particularly Kidman, who doesn't stretch much but is effective as Mrs. Coulter. The enchanting lady, whose daemon is a nasty golden monkey that doesn't talk (fits the character perfectly), really does have ice water flowing through her veins. Also good are Sam Elliott as Texan aeronaut Lee Scoresby and Eva Green as the ethereal witch Serafina Pekkala. But the character who makes the biggest impression, both literally and figuratively, is the armored ice bear Iorek Byrnison, an exiled prince from his homeland of Svalbard who is looking for a little retribution. As voiced by Ian McKellen (who else?), Iorek is definitely a force to be reckoned with every time he is on screen. His bear-on-bear battle with the reigning Svalbardian king, who kicked him out, is one of the film's best moments. Love the character names, too.

Direction

There's a lot going on in The Golden Compass, which might confuse the smaller ones in the audience. Pullman's books are dense, much like the Harry Potter series, and one must stay pretty focused to follow all the film's plot points--some of which will, with any luck, make more sense further down the line. And it is also, at times, hard to stay emotionally involved in the spectacle of it all (the exception is definitely the ice bears). But still, if you allow yourself to be immersed in this fantastical, purely make-believe world of gadgetry, grandeur and austerity, much like the worlds of Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings and Chronicles of Narnia, then you shouldn't be too disappointed with Golden Compass. Even more amazing is the director who came up with the film's vision: Chris Weitz, best known for helming the little British dramedy About a Boy. Maybe not the first choice, but it's clear the director is passionate about the material, as he covers as much ground as possible in the first installment. Probably the most fascinating part are the daemons, who are the animal manifestations of their human counterparts, interconnected in all ways. Some have smaller, domestic animals such as dogs, cats, mice; some, like Lord Asriel, have big animals such as snow leopard; some even have insects. It gets your mind wandering about what yours might be.

Bottom Line

Hollywood.com rated this film 3 stars.

Movie

The Golden Compass

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2007-12-07 15:40:28

Provider

Review

Based on the popular children's novel by Phil Pullman, this first part of the Dark Materials trilogy aims to be New Line's latest fantasy hit following their huge success with The Lord of the Rings.

It certainly has the credentials - the story of a young girl not realising that she is a chosen one in a good vs evil battle may not be the most original, but Pullman's dense, layered tome is more Philip Marlowe than Harry Potter.

Adding to the intelligent - and some might say controversial what with the thinly layered anti-organised religion subtext - source material is a smattering of big names (and uniquely for a fantasy film in the new millennium they haven't all come from RADA) including Nicole Kidman, Daniel Craig and Sam Elliot - the film's spectacular special effects only add to the wow factor.

So why doesn't it set the heart racing as much as it should? Partly the blame lies with director Chris Weitz who doesn't really have the assured hand of say, Peter Jackson.

And while the movie's running time at just under two hours might be welcome relief to parents, who have had to endure regular bum-numbing three hour viewings of The Pirates of the Caribbean, Harry Potter and The Lord Of The Rings series', it just doesn't do this adaptation justice. Many scenes feel rushed as we move to one, admittedly astounding, set-piece after the other.

Kidman is suitably devious as Miss Coulter, with enough savvy to make her character more than just a one-note villain, Craig is excellent as Lord Asriel while Sam Elliot looks like he is having a blast as the air cowboy Lee Scoresby. The trouble is they're not in it nearly enough and while there is nothing wrong with Dakota Blue Richard's lead performance, whenever any of those three are on the screen the film's problems fly away.

Let's hope they feature more in the inevitable sequels.