Stop-Loss Review

"Stop-Loss" reviews

Movie

Stop-Loss

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2008-04-08 20:36:48

Rating

2.5/5

Provider

CinemaSource

Review

When Stop-Loss finally ceases beating around the bush--no, not George W.--it's powerful, stirring and even bipartisan in a sense. Unfortunately, it takes a while to get there.

Story

When U.S. soldiers return home from fighting in Iraq (and obviously anywhere else not touched upon in this movie), the war doesn't necessarily end. Stop- Loss follows a trio of those soldiers--Sgt. Brandon King (Ryan Phillippe), Tommy Burgess (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) and Steve Shriver (Channing Tatum)--from Tikrit all the way back to their small Texas hometown, to which they return heroes. Brandon is the natural-born leader with a solid head on his shoulders; Tommy's head is considerably less solid; and Steve is the textbook alpha-male, quick to explode bits of virility. However, they're all now struggling to adjust to the normalcy of home life--even Brandon, who can't shake the horrifying combat flashbacks. But then Brandon learns that he has been stop-lossed: forced to return to active duty in Iraq against his will. The direct order couldn't have come at a worse time for Brandon, who had just washed his hands of Iraq's atrocities and was planning on staying home for good. Before long, he's AWOL, on his way to Washington, D.C., where he hopes to find the senator who promised to help him. Brandon makes a few painful but necessary pit stops en route to D.C. that further fuel his contempt for the war. Ultimately, he is faced with a can't-win decision that no one should ever have to make.

Acting

The acting in Stop Loss, much like the film itself, runs very hot and cold. For female viewers, of course, it'll all be hot primarily because of Phillippe and Tatum, both of whom are in Army mode (read: shirtless). But the performances are a slightly different story. Phillippe has carved out a niche for himself with these brooding, serious roles of late (i.e., Breach), but they don't seem like much of a stretch. He succeeds for the most part as Stop-Loss' imperiled protagonist, although he has a tendency to kick it into angst overdrive on occasion. Tatum (Step Up), on the other hand, rarely succeeds in the movie and does seem like he's stretching his limits during scenes that call for conveyance of real emotion--scenes of emotional shirtlessness, if you will, as opposed to the physical kind. Indie veteran Gordon-Levitt (The Lookout), as usual, is the best of the bunch, making easy work of the movie's most genuine, complex character. Abbie Cornish (Somersault)--Phillippe's rumored real-life girlfriend--plays Steve's girlfriend and the one with whom Brandon drives across the country. She hides her Australian accent well enough for credibility as a born-and-bred Texan, but her performance and presence are forgettable.

Direction

Writer-director Kimberly Peirce apparently doesn't make movies unless she needs to get something off her chest. Nine years ago, she had something very powerful to say on the subject of (trans)gender discrimination and sexual violence with Boys Don't Cry (for which Hilary Swank won an Oscar), and now the Iraq War is on her brain. Whereas most of today's vocal war opponents simply aim to incite anger and outrage over the war, Peirce does them all one better: She's staunchly anti-war, sure, but she is also pro-soldier, and Stop-Loss is the soldiers' story before it is a Bush diatribe. Peirce is effective at speaking on the soldiers' behalf and making the final third of the film very stirring. But the transition to get to that point? Not so much. The difference between much of the film and its final act is like night and day--or more fittingly, like dramatization and documentary. Stop-Loss is an MTV Films production and feels every bit like it early on, complete with overly juiced-up theatrics and music that detract from the story's humanistic aspect. Which would be one thing if it stayed that course throughout, but it doesn't; it makes an unsubtle turn near the end, switching from a vendetta, man-on-the-run story to an insightful, topical commentary on the war and its soldiers. Fortunately, that commentary outweighs the unevenness.

Bottom Line

Hollywood.com rated this film 2 1/2 stars.

Copyright © CinemaSource 2008.

Movie

Stop-Loss

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2008-04-18 16:40:16

Provider

MRIB

Review

Despite being met with mass indifference from the American public, the Iraq War movies keep on coming. On the surface writer-director Kimberly Peirce was better placed to tackle the issue than many of Hollywood's supposed "liberal elite", since her teenage brother served in Iraq with the US military. But backstory makes no difference here, and Stop-Loss has suffered the same fate as Redacted, Lions For Lambs and many others at the US box office.

Peirce's film deserves a better fate. Unlike its contemporaries, it doesn't offer simple solutions or issue blanket condemnations. Instead it delivers an honest and sympathetic look at the situation of the returning American troops. All are profoundly damaged by their experience: Tommy (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) is turning into a jittery wreck; Steve (Channing Tatum) is in a permanent rage, which he mostly directs at his fiancée, Michelle (Abbie Cornish), Brandon (Ryan Phillippe), the group's sergeant and something close to an ideal soldier, is enraged when the army invoke the 'stop-loss' rule to send him back. This is the law revived by President Bush which allows the military to retain soldiers even after they've served their full terms. Brandon deems stop-loss to be "a backdoor draft" and refuses to go, making him effectively AWOL.

Peirce, who previously wrote and directed transgender drama Boys Don't Cry, bends over backwards to portray the soldiers as victims of an unsympathetic military establishment, while side-stepping the rights and wrongs of the war itself. It's a delicate balancing act, one made slightly less convincing by the manner in which she piles on their post-conflict trauma. But while she's guilty of having her outrage and eating it, Stop-Loss' refusal to patronise either its subjects or its audience makes it the best by a distance of a largely disappointing bunch.

Copyright © MRIB 2008.