Troy Review

"Troy" reviews

Movie

Troy

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2007-04-02 21:27:40

Rating

3.5/5

Provider

CinemaSource

Review

The gods have looked down favorably on Troy and have deemed it a worthy re-telling of Homer's classic The Iliad--an epic tale of love and honor set against the backdrop of one of the greatest wars ever fought. The goddesses, however, can't stop talking about Brad Pitt's pecs.

Story

There have been many ostentatious interpretations of The Iliad, but Troy roots itself in reality instead of trying to tackle both the epic story and all the mythological hullabaloo. As it goes, the ancient Greek King Agamemnon (Brian Cox) builds his vast empire by conquering one country after another with the help of the warrior Achilles (Brad Pitt). Yet, Achilles holds no allegiance to Agamemnon, or any king for that matter, fighting only so that he will be remembered as the greatest warrior of all time, while also agonizing over the death and mayhem he causes. Agamemnon rankles at Achilles' insolence but soon has other fish to fry. Seems Agamemnon's brother, Menelaus (Brendan Gleeson), King of Sparta, has had his pride wounded when his lovely wife, Helen (Diane Kruger), is spirited away to the great city of Troy by its lovesick prince, Paris (Orlando Bloom), who fell for the queen when he was visiting Sparta on a peace mission. The scandalous act creates a chain reaction--unleashing the cuckolded Menelaus' need for retribution, Agamemnon's greedy desire to take Troy as his own and Achilles' pursuit of ultimate glory. But Troy's impenetrable walls have been fiercely protected by the Trojan warriors, especially the powerful Prince Hector (Eric Bana), for decades--and they are not about to lay down arms now, even for as fearsome a foe as Achilles. Let the games of war begin.

Acting

The men of Troy have it in spades--flowing hair, rippling muscles and dripping testosterone aplenty. As for the main eye candy, it's a given Pitt is going to look like a god as the formidable Achilles--but the fact the Greek warrior is tormented as well, suits the actor perfectly (remember Legends of the Fall? Who can't?). Pitt handles the pitiful, tortured moments better than most as poor Achilles, with his six-pack abs, struggles with his questionable ethics and actions as well as his place in the world. Troy's other hunk, the warrior Hector, complements his nemesis Achilles nicely. Played by Aussie actor Bana, who audiences might recognize as The Hulk (well, the smaller-sized, more human version of the big, green guy anyway), Hector is just as full of bravado as Achilles yet has a very grounded sense of honor and duty to his country as well as love for his wife Andromache (the billowy Saffron Burrows). Counteracting them both is the infatuated Paris, portrayed effectively by heartthrob Bloom, who has the unenviable task of being the coward surrounded by heroes. Luckily, Paris redeems himself a bit in the end--and we get a brief reminder of Bloom's Lord of the Rings alter-elf Legolas. The veteran actors hold their own among the sweaty he-men, including Cox as the megalomaniac Agamemnon and Peter O'Toole as Paris' and Hector's misguided father, King Priam, who should have listened more closely to his sons. Troy's women do not fare as well, however, especially German model Kruger as Helen. While certainly beautiful enough to play the part, she is relegated to mostly standing around watching the men fight over her, without getting the chance to show any of Helen's spunk. Australian ingénue Rose Byrne gets the most to work with as the virginal Troy priestess Briseis, who is, at first, a captive but then seems to be the only one who can calm Achilles down. Lucky girl.

Direction

Dubbed possibly one of the most expensive movies ever made (the budget reportedly hit about $200 million), Troy's set was plagued with costly crises: Endless production delays, tortuous heat in Malta and Mexico, hurricanes wiping out sets and the star actually injuring his Achilles tendon (no joke). Yet, for all the film's troubles, director Wolfgang Petersen (The Perfect Storm) never lets you see it onscreen. Petersen builds the tension, heightens the calm before the storm and then deftly brings one of the most legendary wars of all time up close and personal, with each of Troy's battle sequences meticulously done--from the all-out beach battle as the Greeks bring their ships to shore to the massive army charge on the walls of Troy to the best of them all--a tragic and an inevitable mano á mano confrontation between Hector and Achilles. If there's any drawback, it's the lag time between the battle scenes, as the men walk around preparing for battle, talk about how to prepare for the battle, spend time with their wives/lovers before the battle, pray to the gods to help them win the battle and so on. It's unavoidable in a movie like this, but much like The Lord of the Rings, at least Troy's story comes from a classic source.

Bottom Line

Greedy kings, lusty virgins, buff heroes, a cast of thousands, huge battle sequences and a face that ''launched a thousand ships''--Troy has it all and then some.

Copyright © CinemaSource 2007.

Movie

TROY

Author

anonymous

Date reviewed

2005-10-27 22:16:48

Provider

MRIB

Review

There's been a huge amount of hype surrounding Wolfgang Petersen's sand and sandals adaptation of Homer's The Iliad, not least because it features some of Hollywood's hottest talent in skirts and lashings of baby oil.

But can the walls of Troy withstand the pressure, or will they crumble under the onslaught from the critics?

Surely we all know the story in one version of another but here's Hollywood's take on things - Helen (Diane Kruger) has left her husband, King Menelaus of Sparta (Brendan Gleeson) and done a runner with Paris (Orlando Bloom), a young prince of Troy. Menelaus beseeches his power hungry brother King Agamemnon (Brian Cox) to go to war with the Trojans and let him have his revenge. Agamemnon agrees - but has his own motives - and calls on Achilles (Brad Pitt), the greatest warrior the world has ever known, to sail with him.

This movie was always going to be a massive undertaking but in most areas Troy is a real triumph. Lavish production values, a star-studded cast, huge action sequences and an epic running time means that it can really lay claim to being a modern-day descendant of such iconic flicks as Ben Hur and Spartacus.

Pitt's reasonable as Achilles and carries off the fight scenes well (more Brad-iator than Gladiator), Sean Bean's battle-weary Odysseus brings back memories of his TV role as Sharpe while Cox snarls and rants as the power-hungry King, hell-bent on ransacking the city.

However, Troy isn't without it's problems and most of them come in the form of Orlando Bloom. Sure the lad's good-looking but he struggles to match the dramatic power of his co-stars such as Peter O'Toole and Cox with his on-screen brother, the excellent Eric Bana, dominating every scene they share. When will folks twig that Bloom isn't actually a very good actor and just got lucky with Lord Of The Rings?

Also when presented with a film with no clear 'baddie', some audiences may struggle with the ethics and morality of their violent heroes.

Still, for a summer blockbuster, Troy is a cracker and, fingers crossed, could even stand the test of time.

Copyright © MRIB 2005.