Five reasons John Carter was a huge flop

Ben Skipper
Movies Blog
13 March 2012

Disney sci-fi flick 'John Carter' has become one of the biggest flops in movie history. The studio have announced that the film's theatrical run will lose them $200m (£126m).

But why has this big-budget epic become such a disaster? We investigated...

[Related story: The biggest flops of 2011]

It's all been done before

The film is based on the pulp novels by Edgar Rice Burroughs, written between 1911 and 1940. The 'John Carter of Mars' stories inspired pretty much all modern sci-fi in some way from 'Star Wars' to 'Avatar', but because of this much of the action has a familiar feel.

Take James Cameron's 'Avatar', which replicates 'Carter's tired fish-out-of-water story and its lanky alien race. An unfortunate shot in the trailers of Carter covered head-to-toe in blue blood really didn't help matters. It's not really fair, but 'Carter' just felt derivative.

[Related story: The biggest A-list bombs]

The title
'John Carter of Mars' tells the audience exactly what to expect; B-movie-style thrills a-plenty. However, the decision to change the name to simply 'John Carter' was just the tip of an iceberg of bad marketing decisions.

A handful of visually stark posters couldn't combat the bland trailers and the result was an insubstantial campaign that did little to help the film. The studio wasn't sure if they wanted families or sci-fi fans to see the film. In the end they got neither.

Taylor Kitsch is not a leading man
Hollywood bigwigs have seemingly decided that Kitsch is The Next Big Thing, with the star headlining 'Carter' and the upcoming 'Battleship'. On the evidence of the former, Tom Cruise shouldn't start losing his sleep just yet.

Kitsch was okay as Carter, but a film based on a series of pretty old books needed a better-known actor in the lead. The supporting cast didn't help. The biggest names attached were Willem Defoe (who voices a CG character) and Mark Strong who, surprise surprise, plays the film's bald villain.

Dr Seuss's The Lorax
The animated feature, which opened opposite 'John Carter' in the US, surprised everyone with a very strong box office showing in its opening week. It then topped charts for the second week in a row, beating the debuting Carter to the spot. The 'toon successfully captured the family audience that Disney were going for and doomed 'Carter' in the process.

The film was boring
None of this would've really mattered of course if 'John Carter' was a really, really good film. It wasn't. The general critical consensus was that it was an over-long, incoherent mess.

The Guardian said 'John Carter' was "oppressive and... interminably long", while USA Today reckoned "the characters are one-dimensional... even in 3-D". With a duff marketing campaign, this needed strong word-of-mouth, which is nigh-on impossible with such dire write-ups.

Hilton HHonors™ Card

Earn 40,000 Hilton HHonors™ Bonus Points. Apply for Your Card Today.

Military Mortgage Rates In 2016

Rates as Low as 2.75% (3.028% APR) 15 Year Fixed. Exclusive For Veteran & Military Takes 1 Min!

Insane Navy Seal Flashlight, should it be banned?

The Military has recently released technology that is now available to the public. Get yours before they run out - Limited Supply!

Make customer support your secret weapon.

Alert your agents! Read Desk.com's free "Startup's Guide to Customer Service" to learn secrets for support success from 8 leading startups.

Do NOT pay your insurance until you try this.

If you drive less than 55 miles/day OR have no DUI's you can get auto insurance for as low as $29/ Month! See if you qualify.

Medicare Supplement Plans For Those Aged 65 And Up

New rates for Medicare supplement plans have arrived. Click here for a free price quote and learn how to improve your current coverage plan.

Banks Feel 'Cheated' When Homeowners Do This

Homeowners are surprised in 2016. Before you pay your mortgage this month, you need to see this. Own a home? Read this now!

Stop Paying Too Much For Your Prescriptions.

Drug prices vary wildly between pharmacies. GoodRx finds the lowest prices and discounts. Compare prices, print free coupons & save up to 80%.

Watch Butterfinger® Ad

Watch Our Bolder Than Bold Big Game Commercial On Our YouTube Page!

Banks Are Worried Homeowners Will Do This.

Homeowners are surprised and furious. If you owe less than $625,000 on your home, you better read this.

9 Cards for People Who Have Great Credit

What card offers up to 5% cash back? And which one offers 24/7 concierge service? See the best credit cards of 2016. Apply online, quickly & easily.

Starwood Credit Card

Earn 25,000 Bonus Starpoints®! Use toward Award Nights or Flights.

Powerful Tactical Flashlight Flying Off Shelves!

This new tactical flashlight was just released to the public and is flying off shelves in the United States. Limited supplies left, act quick!

People In Heavy Credit Card Debt May Not Know This

If you owe more than $15,000, there is a way to pay off credit card debt that few people think of first. (It's not what you think!)