Producers, Director Say Alec Baldwin Lies in Memoir's Claim of Sex Scenes With Underaged Actress

Tatiana Siegel

Fifty Shades of Grey producer Dana Brunetti is calling foul on claims made by Alec Baldwin in his new memoir, Nevertheless.

In the book, published Tuesday, Baldwin claims that when he shot the 2006 indie Mini's First Time, he was misled by the producers about the age of his co-star Nikki Reed, with whom he engages in sex scenes.

"I was forty-seven, and it never occurred to me to ask how old Nikki Reed was. When I found out, just as we finished, that she was seventeen, I flipped out on the producers, who had told me something different," Baldwin writes.

Brunetti, who produced the film along with Kevin Spacey and Evan Astrowsky, says that not only was Baldwin aware of Reed's age (the Twilight star was, in fact, 16 at the time), but also that nothing was ever hidden from him and there was never any incident where the actor later berated the producers over her age.

"It's a lie," Brunetti tells The Hollywood Reporter. "I read it and was like, 'What the f - . Of course he totally knew how old she was. That's why there's no nudity in the movie. He knew before we even cast the movie. I think he's been method acting Trump too much and he doesn't know the difference between fake news anymore."

Read more: Alec Baldwin Memoir 'Nevertheless': 10 Biggest Revelations

Though nudity under 18 is potentially allowable under California law, it would need to be approved by the Child Labor Board. At the age of 17, Thora Birch briefly appeared topless in American Beauty, but it was not in a sex scene. But because Mini's First Time involved sex scenes between Baldwin and Reed, nudity would not have been approved.

Astrowsky also backed up Brunetti's version.

"What Alec says happened is not accurate. I completely corroborate that," Astrowsky tells THR. "We were on set every day. The thing that Alec must remember is that Mini, played by Nikki, is a sophomore in high school. I don't know what else to say, except Alec, watch the movie. As for yelling at us after the movie, it absolutely never happened."

And the film's writer and director Nick Guthe also threw water on Baldwin's version of events.

"We all knew she was 16. When we discussed it at first, it was a question of meeting with her and making sure she was mature enough to handle the role," Guthe tells THR. "On the set, Nikki, being 16, would often speak quickly the way teenagers do, and Alec asked me about that at times because he had trouble understanding her, and I would remind him, 'She's 16.'"

Guthe says he is surprised that Baldwin's story wasn't fact-checked by publisher Harper. (Even Baldwin's age is incorrectly stated. He was 46 when the film shot in October 2004 in Los Angeles.)

Brunetti, who shares the same CAA agent as Baldwin and Spacey, recalls that during casting, it came down to four actresses, and the actor handpicked Reed, who also was repped by CAA at the time. Also undercutting Baldwin's claim is the fact that Reed's biggest role at that point was the 2003 breakout Thirteen, the title of which references Reed's character's (and the actress') age.

Read more: Dominic West to Star in Jameson First Shot Competition Films From Producer Dana Brunetti (Exclusive)

What has Brunetti fuming is that Baldwin would malign the producers' reputations.

"If he had just said, 'I didn't know her age,' I would have thought, 'He's a liar,' and let it go," says Brunetti. "But when he blamed the producers, I couldn't let it go. It [makes us look like] we did something unethical or shady or hid something. It makes me look bad. It makes Evan look bad. Does he realize Kevin was a producer?"

Though Baldwin declined comment earlier in the day, he fired back at Brunetti in a series of angry tweets, maintaining, "I was told she was 16 by her hairdresser. At the end of the shoot. You're already buried." Baldwin also demanded, "SAG rules require releases for scenes involving physical contact with minors. I take you have a copy of that?"

Brunetti, in response, shot back at Baldwin, "As the president of the Film Actors Guild, you should be able to easily access them." The actor then replied, "Dana, produce the releases, you Hollywood zombie, and you're all good. ... I'm doing @matchgameabc so I don't have to work w guys like u..."

@DanaBrunetti @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am SAG rules require releases for scenes involving physical contact with minors. I take you have a copy of that?

- ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) April 5, 2017

@ABFalecbaldwin @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am If required, I'm sure there is one. But really, are you going to continue to deny that you didn't know she was 16?? I'll bury you.

- Dana Brunetti (@DanaBrunetti) April 5, 2017

@DanaBrunetti @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am I was told she was 16 by her hairdresser. At the end of the shoot.


You're already buried.- ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) April 5, 2017

@DanaBrunetti @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am Dana, produce the releases, you Hollywood zombie, and you're all good

- ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) April 5, 2017

@DanaBrunetti @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am I'm doing @matchgameabc so I don't have to work w guys like u...

- ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) April 5, 2017

@ABFalecbaldwin @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am @matchgameabc You mean my Oscar nominated films? Nice plug by the way. When are you gonna come out to the 310 with a chain and show us how it's done?

- Dana Brunetti (@DanaBrunetti) April 5, 2017

@DanaBrunetti @TatianaSiegel27 @NickGuthe @NikkiReed_I_Am @matchgameabc Do me 1 favor? Just teach me how to bankrupt a company like Relativity. I want to put it in a screenplay I'm working on.


Oh. Get the waiver.- ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) April 5, 2017

The back-and-forth continued on Brunetti's personal Twitter page, on which he called out Baldwin in a separate tweet: "The problem with Hollywood is they cower to blowhard bullies like @ABFalecbaldwin. He can't handle when someone like me stands up to him."

Baldwin again left a comment: "No wonder Spacey fired you."

Spacey hasn't responded to THR's request for a response.

As for Astrowsky's reaction to being thrown under the bus by Baldwin, he says. "And here I was gonna vote for him for president in 2020. He just lost my vote."

4:40 p.m.: Updated with Baldwin's tweets aimed at Brunetti.