Hellboy reviews round-up: The first dud of the year has arrived

The reviews of Hellboy are in – and they’re not pretty.

For those wanting a graphic novel adaptation similar to Guillermo del Toro’s, it seems they’ll be forced to look elsewhere. Director Neil Marshall has taken over the reins for this reboot with Stranger Things star David Harbour in the role played by Ron Perlman in 2004 and again in 2008 for the sequel The Golden Army (he stepped down when del Toro’s third film was shelved)

Based on Mike Mignola’s source material, this R-rated film follows the character as he battles an ancient sorceress (Milla Jovovich) bent on revenge after becoming caught between the worlds of the supernatural and human.

While Harbour’s performance is receiving praise, the reviews are calling the reboot of the Hellboy franchise a mess of the tallest order. It seems we have the year’s first dud.

Read a roundup below.

The Independent

British director Neil Marshall’s reboot of the Hellboy franchise is a lurid, confusing mess, only partially redeemed by its tongue-in-cheek humour and fitfully impressive visual effects.

Variety

It’s lunging to be a badass hard-R epic, but it’s basically a pile of origin-story gobbledygook, frenetic and undercooked, full of limb-hacking, eye-gouging monster battles as well as an atmosphere of apocalyptic grunge that signifies next to nothing.

[[gallery-0]]

The Guardian

For all the badass attitude and the CGI mini-apocalypses he has to stride through, this Hellboy is lacking, more of a Heckboy: a banal action-movie figure, without much of the unexpected likability and indeed the romantic interest that Selma Blair once gave him. Now he just has a series of ho-hum subordinate characters, to be revived, or not, depending on whether the numbers justify more films in this vein.

Vulture

So, Hellboy’s a mess. That’s not to say that it’s complicated, or unclear, exactly; no story filled with this many clichés can really be too confusing. But the latest adaptation of Mike Mignola’s cult comics — an attempt to reboot the successful, if short-lived, film franchise Guillermo del Toro started back in 2004 — throws so many tired plot points and revelations at us that it all feels like an exhausting blur.

Forbes

Hellboy is the kind of reboot that makes reboots look bad.

Scroll through the below gallery to see 35 great films that bombed at the box office.

Hellboy is in cinemas tomorrow (12 April)